Tuesday, August 21, 2012

Good blasts commission



Geri Kamenz
Lawyer Donald Good has written a blistering letter to Geri Kamenz, chairman of the Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission, accusing the commission staff of helping the Egg Farmers of Ontario EFO) marketing board prepare a defence against the petition he filed on behalf of Svante Lind of Verified Eggs.

“To have allowed the General Manager (Harry Pelissero) and Counsel (Geoffrey Spurr) for EFO to work together with senior staff of the Commission to build the EFO defence creates a very significant conflict of interest.

“There are other emails which make it appear that Commission staff are working very closely with EFO to protect EFO's position against the allegations in the Petition, including one where Mr. Pelissero is pleased with your response,” Good has written to Kamenz.

The petition is one that Good filed in January, 2011, asking the commission to launch a public inquiry into the egg industry.

Lind has sued the egg board, L.H. Gray and Son Ltd. and Burnbrae Farms, accusing them of conspiracy to drive him out of the egg-grading business. He has, in fact, subsequently sold Best Choice Eggs.

Good notes in his letter that Kamenz led him to believe as recently as this August that the commission has yet to make a decision about launching the inquiry and/or investigations requested in his petition of January, 2011.

He notes that the recent release of documents through the Freedom of Information system reveals that the commission in fact decided in April of 2011 that it will not hold either a public inquiry or an investigation into allegations Norman Bourdeau filed with the commission.

Good also wrote that “EFO has an extreme bias in presenting and building its best defence to the allegations of wrongdoing and the Commission has not even asked the Petitioner (Lind) for its evidence to support the allegations.”

Kamenz has declined repeated requests from Good to meet with the commission to discuss the allegations and evidence.
                                   
Good wrapped up his letter to Kamenz, writing “the Farm Products Marketing Act is farmer protection legislation.

“I trust that as a former president of Ontario's premier farm organization (the Ontario Federation of Agriculture) representing the well being of farmers, farmer protection is still your major concern.”

Frankly, I can't see how the provincial government can allow Kamenz to continue.