Sunday, July 28, 2013

Cornering the market on aluminum


Goldman Sachs has 1.5 million tons of aluminum ingots in storage,  enough to drive up the price of aluminum, says David Kocieniewski of the New York Times.

It’s what used to be called “cornering the market” to pocket profits.

It’s what farmers suspected grain traders were doing, prompting them to lobby for creation of the Canadian Wheat Board.

In the United States, it prompted politicians to enact the Bank Holding Company Act, designed to keep banks from owning commodities.

That act and other regulations that curbed the banks are gone, swept aside in the rush to deregulation and reduced taxation in the 1990s.

But even with relaxed regulation, it seems that Goldman Sachs stepped over the line.

Global trading rules say banks can only hold minerals for a certain length of time – a regulation designed to keep them from stockpiling so much that the market is short and prices rise.

Goldman Sachs, says Kocieniewski, skirted around this regulation by paying truckers to move its aluminum ingots among warehouses near Detroit.

JP Morgan Chase, another big bank, is facing a $500-million fine for manipulating the electricity markets in California and Michigan.

Barclay’s Bank was recently fined $435 million for manipulating the energy market in California.

So far there is no indication that there are any current investigations into cornering markets for farm commodities.

Greed results in these kinds of abuses; it’s why regulations are required to keep greed in check.

Who's keeping watch on the greed of Canada's marketing boards? It seems to me that Glenn Black out there on Manitoulin Island got a better handle on the greed involved in combining cost-of-production pricing in the poultry industry and inflated feed costs than years of regulatory neglect by the likes of the Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission and the Farm Products Council of Canada.